Intrauterine Devices, or IUDs, are not new–but their popularity is rising. 8% of women aged 15-44 in the U.S. choose IUDs to keep watch over their uteruses. And in the last year, there’s been a rather, well, interesting spike in IUD use. Athena insight reported a 30% increase in visits for IUD procedures and according to Planned Parenthood, demand for IUDs is up 900% since last November.
Many say that IUDs are the most effective form of birth control on the market today–and study after study deems them safe for women of all childbearing ages. A 2015 study even showed that women’s health providers use IUDs more than any other form of contraception. We’ll have what they’re having!
So why are IUDs so popular?
- They're 99% effective. Studies have even shown that the IUD is comparable to female sterilization (which is cray) with cumulative pregnancy rates at 5 years of <0.5%.
- They last. Your IUD can stay in your body 3-12 years depending on the type you get. Think set it and forget it–crockpot style.
- They’re reversible. Once you decide you’re ready for something new, you can have it removed and you should be able to return to your normal cycle
- They don’t mess with estrogen. Which means less side effects than the pill. Hormonal IUDs release a localized hormone and copper IUDs don’t contain hormones at all. More on that later.
- They’re free (at least for now). In May 2015 the Obama administration stated that under the Affordable Care Act, at least one form of all 18 FDA-approved methods of birth control, including the IUD must be covered without a co-payment–even if you haven’t met your deductible. We’re hoping that despite recent news–it stays that way.
Ok, awesome. Why has it taken so long for IUDs to hit the big time?
If you live in the U.S. you might vaguely remember hearing something about IUDs and abortions and infertility. (Don’t worry, IUDs do not cause abortions or infertility). But there was a big controversy–call it the IUD version of “Serial”–in the 80s that gave them a pretty bad rep. It all had to do with the release of the Dalkon Shield—one faulty IUD that let bacteria into the uterus causing inflammation, infection, and infertility. Not good. The incident ruined our IUD trust in the U.S. for years to come. Meanwhile, the rest of the world charged ahead. China, France, Scandanavia (fun fact, 25% of Scandanavian women rely on IUDs!) kept on using their safe and effective IUDs.
We now have nearly 30 years of science (and we like our science) to back up the truth of the IUD on the market—that they’re safe and effective. Now, that doesn’t mean there aren’t risks (we’ll get into those a bit later). But all IUDs recommended by doctors today are FDA approved and are quickly overcoming the label placed on them so many years ago.
So, How Does the IUD Work?
The IUD is a small T-shaped device (adorable, really) that takes about five minutes to place inside your cervix. There are two types of IUDs: hormonal and copper.
Hormonal IUD: Sperm shall not pass
Mirena, Skyla, Liletta, and Kyleena are not just adorable names for your new puppy—they’re the four brands of hormonal IUDs currently available. Also, please let us know if you name your dog after an IUD–because that’s awesome. Hormonal IUDs block sperm from getting to the egg by:
- Releasing levonorgestrel (a progestogen) to keep ovaries from releasing eggs. (Unlike birth control pills which release hormones into your bloodstream, this is a localized hormone release–just in your uterus).
- Thickening the mucus of the cervix so the sperm can’t reach the egg.
- Inhibiting the sperm’s ability to swim toward the egg.
- The differences between these three puppies are:
- The amount of hormone released (Kyleena, for example, releases 17.5 micrograms/day while Mirena releases 20).
- The size: Skyla and Kyleena are slightly smaller and have a narrower inserter, so insertion may be a bit more comfortable–which is all kinds of good.
- The approved length of use: Skyla is effective for up to three years–Mirena for five. Since all four release a progestogen, they may lead to lighter and shorter periods–or no period at all.
Copper IUD: Not a sperm favorite
The other IUD option is the copper IUD, brand name ParaGard. It works by releasing copper ions into your cervix–no hormones here. Copper makes your uterus a pretty hostile environment for sperm. Your cervix begins to produce a thick mucus that sperm can’t navigate navigate through to get to your egg.
(FYI: conception is defined as a fertilized egg implanting in the uterine wall. So, the abortion fear isn’t an issue because conception never actually occurs). And on top of that, copper actually, um…decapitates sperm. So yeah, no fertilization.
Okay so which IUD to choose? Let’s talk side effects first.
The fine print
IUDs are not the magical answer (even if they might seem that way)–they do have listed side effects. Paragard lays out like anemia, backaches (interesting), cramping, irregular periods, and vaginal inflammation. Although there aren’t hormonal side effects, women report heavier periods and cramping with this bad boy. Mirena, Skyla, Liletta, and Kyleena all site risks of nausea, ovarian cysts, and mood changes.
Both forms of IUD come with the risk of accidental “perforation” or, well, a hole in the uterus–and “expulsion” of the IUD. Expulsion, you ask? Yeah. There is a small chance that the IUD can slip out of your uterus. Planned Parenthood assures us that this is very rare (occurring between 2 and 10% of women), usually due to improper insertion. Doctors do a “string check” about 6 weeks after insertion (there are little teenie strings on the bottom of the IUD for removal) to make sure it’s in there nice and snug.
To IUD or not to IUD
Despite the watchouts, studies have deemed both IUD types as “highly acceptable with few unanticipated side effects.” And although the copper IUD is slightly more effective (with pregnancy rates between 0.3% and 0.6%) the hormonal IUD is only slightly less effective at (<0.5%). So which to choose? Talk to your doctor and she’ll walk you through it.
- She’ll make sure you’re a great candidate by ensuring you’re not already pregnant and don’t have any infections.
- She’ll then ask you about your sexual history and check the position of your uterus.
- If you want to avoid hormones, she may suggest you choose copper or, since the hormones are localized and don’t have as broad of an impact as the pill, she may still recommend a hormonal IUD. If you have heavy bleeding she may have you avoid Paragard–which can make things really flow.
A hot topic
IUDs are front and center in the birth control conversation and more and more women are talking about the liberation they promise and the hesitation they provoke (IUDs have definitely been a conversation piece at our book club over the last few months). For all the women who love them, there are still women who loathe them.
Christine calls her Mirena IUD “A godsend.” She needed a birth control method that made, “less of an impact” on her hormones and, “as someone who is massively impacted by hormones, it’s been a breeze. Not getting a period is the best.”
Sarah had similar feelings, “My periods are light to non-existent. I never have to think about taking a pill. I haven’t experienced any weight gain or heightened emotions. I feel steadier than ever, as if PMS has been mitigated.”
Shannon didn’t end up getting an IUD because she didn’t like that she may not get a period. “For me, I like knowing that everything’s working. It’s not that I love getting my period–but I don’t actually mind it. Makes me feel like a woman."
And for some women, like Kate, the IUD just straight up wasn't right. Kate says, “My copper IUD made me bloated and gave me a heavier period than ever. I had it removed a few months in. I may try a hormonal one down the road but I’m not sure it’s the right thing for my body."
And finally...what’s it like getting the thing up there?
This part we can fill you in on from personal experience. Here’s how it goes down.
Your gynecologist “installs” (not sure that’s the medical term, but that’s definitely what it feels like) the IUD into your cervix using a device that can only be described as an vaginal electric toothbrush. There is speculum action. There is cramping action. There is spotting. It’s not I-need-to-lie-in-my-bed-right-now cramping, but almost. And how to describe the feeling? It’s not a tampon in your vagina feeling, it’s an “oh… oh okay, that’s different,” kind of feeling. Overall it’s not excruciating. But it’s not comfortable. Your doctor may recommend taking an Ibuprofen or two one hour before your appointment. And then you’ll go about your life enjoying the perks of sextual empowerment knowing you’re locked and loaded with safe, effective contraception.
Okay one last thing
Remember remember remember that IUDs protect against pregnancy but not in the slightest from STDs (we know they changed it to STI at some point in high school but we’re old fashioned). If you and your partner haven’t been tested for all the things–keep the condoms handy. One last last thing. We’re here to arm you with info. But only your doctor can give you medical advice. If you're thinking through BC options, talk to her first.
CDC, Key Statistics from the National Survey of Family Growth ( 2011-2015)
Athena Insight As ACA debate continues, IUD visits keep climbing (2017)
Patrick F. Thonneau, Thierry E. Almont, Contraceptive efficacy of intrauterine devices, In American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, (2008)
Rivera R; Farr G; Chi IC. The copper IUD: safe and effective. The international experience of Family Health International. Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, Family Health International (1992)
Stern, Lisa F. et al. Differences in contraceptive use between family planning providers and the U.S. population: results of a nationwide survey Contraception , Volume 91 , Issue 6 , 464 - 469
Ljiljana Randic, Savo Vlasic, Ivan Matrljan, Cynthia S. Waszak, Return to fertility after IUD removal for planned pregnancy, In Contraception (1985)
Tatum HJ, Schmidt FH, Phillips D, McCarty M, O'Leary WM. The Dalkon Shield Controversy Structural and Bacteriological Studies of IUD Tails. JAMA (1975)
Haimovich S, Profile of long-acting reversible contraception users in Europe.Eur J Contracept Reprod Health Care. 2009
Hubacher, David. Finer, Lawrence B., Espey, Eve.Renewed interest in intrauterine contraception in the United States: Evidence and explanation. Contraception , Volume 83 , Issue 4 , 291 - 294
Jennifer L. Hayes, Carrie Cwiak, Peggy Goedken, Miriam Zieman, A pilot clinical trial of ultrasound-guided postplacental insertion of a levonorgestrel intrauterine device, In Contraception, Volume 76, Issue 4, 2007, Pages 292-296, ISSN 0010-7824, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.contraception.2007.06.003.
Tapani Luukkainen, Pekka Lähteenmäki & Juhani Toivonen Levonorgestrel-Releasing Intrauterine Device Annals of Medicine Vol. 22 , Iss. 2,1990
The ESHRE Capri Workshop Group; Family planning 2011: better use of existing methods, new strategies and more informed choices for female contraception, Human Reproduction Update, Volume 18, Issue 6, 1 November 2012
Ott, Mary A. & Sucato, Gina S. Contraception for Adolescents (October 2014). American Academy of Pediatrics, 134 (4).
Contraceptives Used in the United States (September, 2016). Guttmacher Center for Population Research Innovation and Dissemination. Retrieved from https://www.guttmacher.org/fact-sheet/contraceptive-use-united-states
Long-Acting Reversible Contraception: Implants and Intrauterine Devices, The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. (July 2011)
Health during prolonged use of levonorgestrel 20 micrograms/d and the copper TCu 380Ag intrauterine contraceptive devices: a multicenter study. International Committee for Contraception Research (ICCR) (1994).